The
Administration Of The Pulitzer Prizes
More than 2,000 entries are submitted each year in the Pulitzer Prize competitions,
and only 21 awards are normally made. The awards are the culmination of
a year-long process that begins early in the year with the appointment of
102 distinguished judges who serve on 20 separate juries and are asked to
make three nominations in each of the 21 categories. By February 1, the
Administrator's office in the Columbia School of Journalism has received
the journalism entries -in 2000, typically 1,516. Entries for journalism
awards may be submitted by any individual from material appearing in a United
States newspaper published daily, Sunday, or at least once a week during
the calendar year. In early March, 77 editors, publishers, writers, and
educators gather in the School of Journalism to judge the entries in the
14 journalism categories. From 1964-1999 each journalism jury consisted
of five members. Due to the growing number of entries in the public service,
investigative reporting, beat reporting, feature writing and commentary
categories, these juries were enlarged to seven members beginning in 1999.
The jury members, working intensively for three days, examine every entry
before making their nominations. Exhibits in the public service, cartoon,
and photography categories are limited to 20 articles, cartoons, or pictures,
and in the remaining categories, to 10 articles or editorials - except for
feature writing, which has a maximum of five articles. In photography, a
single jury judges both the Breaking News category and the Feature category.
Since the inception of the prizes the journalism categories have been expanded
and repeatedly redefined by the board to keep abreast of the evolution of
American journalism. The cartoons prize was created in 1922. The prize for
photography was established in 1942, and in 1968 the category was divided
into spot or breaking news and feature. With the development of computer-altered
photos, the board stipulated in 1995 that "no entry whose content is manipulated
or altered, apart from standard newspaper cropping and editing, will be
deemed acceptable."
These
are the Pulitzer Prize category definitions in the 2002 competition:
1.
For a distinguished example of meritorious public service by a newspaper
through the use of its journalistic resources which may include editorials,
cartoons, and photographs, as well as reporting.
2.
For a distinguished example of local reporting of breaking news.
3.
For a distinguished example of investigative reporting by an individual
or team, presented as a single article or series.
4.
For a distinguished example of explanatory reporting that illuminates
a significant and complex subject, demonstrating mastery of the subject,
lucid writing and clear presentation.
5.
For a distinguished example of beat reporting characterized by sustained
and knowledgeable coverage of a particular subject or activity.
6.
For a distinguished example of reporting on national affairs.
7.
For a distinguished example of reporting on international affairs, including
United Nations correspondence.
8.
For a distinguished example of feature writing giving prime consideration
to high literary quality and originality.
9.
For distinguished commentary.
10.
For distinguished criticism.
11.
For distinguished editorial writing, the test of excellence being clearness
of style, moral purpose, sound reasoning, and power to influence public
opinion in what the writer conceives to be the right direction.
12.
For a distinguished cartoon or portfolio of cartoons published during
the year, characterized by originality, editorial effectiveness, quality
of drawing, and pictorial effect.
13.
For a distinguished example of breaking news photography in black and
white or color, which may consist of a photograph or photographs, a sequence
or an album.
14.
For a distinguished example of feature photography in black and white
or color, which may consist of a photograph or photographs, a sequence
or an album.
While
the journalism process goes forward, shipments of books totaling some
800 titles are being sent to five letters juries for their judging in these categories:
- For
distinguished fiction by an American author, preferably dealing with
American life.
- For
a distinguished book upon the history of the United States.
- For
a distinguished biography or autobiography by an American author.
- For
a distinguished volume of original verse by an American author.
- For
a distinguished book of non-fiction by an American author that is not
eligible for consideration in any other category.
The
award in poetry was established in 1922 and that for non-fiction in 1962.
Unlike the other awards which are made for works in the calendar year,
eligibility in drama and music extends from March 2 to March 1. The drama
jury of four critics and one academic attend plays both in New York and
the regional theaters. The award in drama goes to a playwright but production
of the play as well as script are taken into account.
The
music jury, usually made up of four composers and one newspaper critic,
meet in New York to listen to recordings and study the scores of pieces,
which in 2000 numbered 100. The category definition states:
For distinguished musical composition of significant
dimension by an American that has had its first performance in the United
States during the year.
The
final act of the annual competition is enacted in early April when the
board assembles in the Pulitzer World Room of the Columbia School of Journalism.
In prior weeks, the board had read the texts of the journalism entries
and the 15 nominated books, listened to music cassettes, read the scripts
of the nominated plays, and attended the performances or seen videos where
possible. By custom, it is incumbent on board members not to vote on any
award under consideration in drama or letters if they have not seen the
play or read the book. There are subcommittees for letters and music whose
members usually give a lead to discussions. Beginning with letters and
music, the board, in turn, reviews the nominations of each jury for two
days. Each jury is required to offer three nominations but in no order
of preference, although the jury chair in a letter accompanying the submission
can broadly reflect the views of the members. Board discussions are animated
and often hotly debated. Work done by individuals tends to be favored.
In journalism, if more than three individuals are cited in an entry, any
prize goes to the newspaper. Awards are usually made by majority vote,
but the board is also empowered to vote 'no award,' or by three-fourths
vote to select an entry that has not been nominated or to switch nominations
among the categories. If the board is dissatisfied with the nominations
of any jury, it can ask the Administrator to consult with the chair by
telephone to ascertain if there are other worthy entries. Meanwhile, the
deliberations continue.
Both
the jury nominations and the awards voted by the board are held in strict
confidence until the announcement of the prizes, which takes place about
a week after the meeting in the World Room. Towards three o'clock p.m.
(Eastern Time) of the day of the announcement, in hundreds of newsrooms
across the United States, journalists gather about news agency tickers
to wait for the bulletins that bring explosions of joy and celebrations
to some and disappointment to others. The announcement is made precisely
at three o'clock after a news conference held by the administrator in
the World Room. Apart from accounts carried prominently by newspapers,
television, and radio, the details appear on the Pulitzer Web site. The
announcement includes the name of the winner in each category as well
as the names of the other two finalists. The three finalists in each category
are the only entries in the competition that are recognized by the Pulitzer
office as nominees. The announcement also lists the board members and
the names of the jurors (which have previously been kept confidential
to avoid lobbying.)
A
gold medal is awarded to the winner in Public Service. Along with the
certificates in the other categories, there are cash awards of $7,500,
raised in 2001 from $5,000. Four Pulitzer fellowships of $5,000 each are
also awarded annually on the recommendation of the faculty of the School
of Journalism. They enable three of its outstanding graduates to travel,
report, and study abroad and one fellowship is awarded to a graduate who
wishes to specialize in drama, music, literary, film, or television criticism.
For most recipients of the Pulitzer prizes, the cash award is only incidental
to the prestige accruing to them and their works. There are numerous competitions
that bestow far larger cash awards, yet which do not rank in public perception
on a level with the Pulitzers. The Pulitzer accolade on the cover of a
book or on the marquee of a theater where a prize-winning play is being
staged usually does translate into commercial gain.
The
Pulitzer process initially was funded by investment income from the original
endowment. But by the 1970s the program was suffering a loss each year.
In 1978 the advisory board established a foundation for the creation of
a supplementary endowment, and fund raising on its behalf continued through
the 1980s. The program is now comfortably funded with investment income
from the two endowments and the $50 fee charged for each entry into the
competitions. The investment portfolios are administered by Columbia University.
Members of the Pulitzer Prize Board and journalism jurors receive no compensation.
The jurors in letters, music, and drama, in appreciation of their year-long
work, receive honoraria, raised to $2,000, effective in 1999.
Unlike
the elaborate ceremonies and royal banquets attendant upon the presentation
of the Nobel Prizes in Stockholm and Oslo, Pulitzer winners receive their
prizes from the president of Columbia University at a modest luncheon
in May in the rotunda of the Low Library in the presence of family members,
professional associates, board members, and the faculty of the School
of Journalism. The board has declined offers to transform the occasion
into a television extravaganza.
The
Who's Who of Pulitzer Prize Winners
is more than simply a roster of names and biographical data. It is a list
of people in journalism, letters, and music whose accomplishments enable
researchers to trace the historical evolution of their respective fields
and the development of American society. We are indebted to Joseph Pulitzer
for this and an array of other contributions to the quality of our lives.
Seymour Topping was
appointed Administrator of The Pulitzer Prizes and Professor of International
Journalism at the Graduate School of Journalism of Columbia University
in 1993. After serving in World War II, Professor Topping worked for 10
years for The Associated Press as a correspondent in China, Indochina,
London, and Berlin. He left The Associated Press in 1959 to join The
New York Times, where he remained for 34 years, serving as a foreign
correspondent, foreign editor, managing editor, and editorial director
of the company's 32 regional newspapers. In 1992-1993 he served as president
of the American Society of Newspaper Editors. He is a graduate of the
School of Journalism at the University of Missouri.
Adapted
from Who's Who of Pulitzer Prize
Winners by Elizabeth A. Brennan and Elizabeth C. Clarage, copyright
1999 by The Oryx Press. Used with permission from The Oryx Press, 4041
N. Central Ave., Suite 700 Phoenix, AZ 85012, 800 279-6799. www.oryxpress.com.
|