Merits
of New Urbanism
The standards
and principles of new urbanism are designed to make areas more livable,
more vibrant, and more people-oriented, and to build community pride in
the city and the work of its developers.
The people-oriented,
traditional areas of the city share a number of desirable characteristics
that provide us with many benefits. We should strive to preserve, celebrate,
encourage and emulate how these areas are designed because of such benefits.
For example, a traditionally designed city provides the following benefits:
1- Gives people without
access to a car, such as children, the elderly, and the disabled, more
safety and independence in their world.
2- Enhances
urban livability, which reduces the desire to flee to the suburbs, which,
in turn, reduces the pressure for costly sprawl and strip commercial development.
3- Substantially
reduces government and household costs -- especially because of the enormous
savings in the building and maintaining of road infrastructure, and the
purchase and maintenance of cars.
4- Reduces
the need for travel.
5- Helps
retain historic structures instead of replacing them with parking or large
suburban retail "boxes""
6- Features
streets designed to slow traffic. It increases travel choices and reduces
the length and number of vehicle trips.
7- Makes
neighborhoods more memorable and dignified.
8- Contains
structures built for permanence, instead of structures designed, as too
many contemporary structures are, for a short-term "throw-away" life.
9-
Integrates income
groups by mixing housing types and providing a public realm available
to all incomes.
10-
Makes walking feel more enjoyable.
11-
Is not characterized
as much by strip commercial visual blight.
12-
Increases citizen
access to culture.
13-
Creates a good environment for smaller, locally-owned businesses to become
established and to operate in.
14-
Puts "eyes on the street" and promotes "citizen surveillance" of public
places where citizens watch over their collective security, crime is reduced,
as are public law enforcement costs.
15-
Stabilizes, reinforces the identity of, and improves the value of nearby
older neighborhoods.
16-
Preserves and promotes community character.
17- Promotes
neighborhood and community self-sufficiency and, therefore, sustainabilty.
18-
Reduces per capita gasoline consumption and air pollution.
19- Coupled
with regulations that are designed to promote and preserve its features,
restores the traditional citizen hope and expectation for a better future
with each new development in the city, and, in so doing, reduces the extreme
polarization between developers and neighborhoods.
20-
Provides affordable housing options.
21-
Creates a sense of place, a sense of community, a sense of belonging and
restores civic pride and place-based loyalty.
22-
Strikes a balance between the needs of the car and the needs of the pedestrian.
It creates a pedestrian ambiance and interesting pedestrian features,
and makes the pedestrian feel safe, convenienced, and comfortable.
23- Creates
a good environment for smaller, locally-owned businesses to become established
and to operate in.
24- Increases
transit viability, primarily through density, access, traffic calming,
community-serving facilities, compactness, mixed use and pedestrian amenities.
Currently,
developers are often reviled and their developments feared. This is manifested
in the contemporary epidemic of NIMBYs (not in my backyard), NIMTOOs (not
in my term of office), BANANAs (build absolutely nothing anywhere near
anything), and NOPEs (not on planet earth). Largely, these attitudes have
emerged because since WWII, developers and cities have sought to make
cars instead of people happy.
Typically, American
suburbs are characterized by this design. Suburban design features:
1- Large
setbacks that are inconvenient for pedestrians and fail to define a comfortable
public realm
2- Large
parking lots in front of buildings
3- Large
street blocks with no cross access or connecting streets
4- Buildings
with their backs or sides turned toward the street. Instead of an entrance
or windows, the pedestrian is confronted with blank walls, air compressors,
dumpsters, and long walks to the building
5- Pedestrian-hostile
features that are designed to promote car use, such as drive-throughs,
single-use zoning, segregation of land uses, and "armoring" with fences
and walls
To make Gainesville
a safer, more livable place, and to increase citizen pride in its developments,
the new urbanist standards are designed to primarily promote the health,
safety, and welfare of pedestrians, while still accommodating the needs
of the car. More specifically, the design is intended to make the pedestrian
feel:
-
Safe and secure
- Convenienced
- Pleasant
and comfortable
With enhanced safety,
livability, civic pride, and visual appeal in these older parts of the
city, the city will establish an important engine in job recruitment and
a strengthened tax base. A downtown that adheres to these standards will
be a city that provides an important incubator for new, entrepreneurial,
locally-owned small businesses and entry-level job opportunities. A healthy
downtown also protects the property values of surrounding residential
areas.
Some
Principles of New Urbanism
|
|
Build-To
Line
Overly
large setbacks are inconvenient and unpleasant for pedestrians. They are
inconvenient because they can significantly increase walking distances
from the public sidewalk. They are unpleasant because they prevent the
pedestrian on the public sidewalk from enjoying the building details and
the activity within the building. In addition, they prevent the building
from contributing to an intimate, pleasant, comfortable street wall, which
harms the sense of place and makes the pedestrian feel as if she or he
is in "no man's land." Buildings pulled up to the street sidewalk have
more of a human scale. The intent of a build-to line is to pull the building
facade up to the street to abut the streetside sidewalk. By doing so,
building facades along a block face will be aligned to form a street wall
that frames the public realm, while retaining sufficient width for people
to walk, and sufficient space to provide a formal landscape created by
the shade of street trees. The street wall shapes the public realm to
provide a sense of comfort and security for the public space.
Building Height of At Least Two Stories
"Low-slung" one-story
buildings are more appropriate in low-density residential areas designed
for motor vehicle travel. They reduce the density and intensity needed
to make transit, walking, and bicycling viable, and typically are too
low in profile to form a desirable, intimate, comfortable public realm
with facing buildings across the street. They also reduce the opportunity
to create mixed-use buildings containing, typically, both commercial and
residential uses. Low-rise multi-story buildings two to five stories in
height are an important component of the compact, walkable city. The building
profile forms the desired street wall and the additional stories allow
the establishment of the number of residents needed for a viable urban
neighborhood.
Parking
Located at the Rear or Side of Building Instead of in Front
Parking areas
located in front of buildings are inconvenient and unpleasant for pedestrians.
They are inconvenient because they significantly increase walking distances
from the public sidewalk. They are unpleasant because they often make
for hot expanses of areas to walk in, prevent the pedestrian on the public
sidewalk from enjoying the building details and the activity within the
building, and increase safety problems since pedestrians must dodge cars
in the parking area. In addition, they prevent the building from contributing
to an intimate, pleasant, comfortable street wall, which harms the sense
of place and makes the pedestrian feel as if she or he is in "no man's
land." Buildings pulled up to the street without intervening motor vehicle
parking have more of a human scale.
Hidden
Trash and Recycling Receptacles and Loading Docks
Trash and recycling
receptacles and loading docks typically provide an unsightly appearance
and an odor problem for pedestrians. In addition, improperly located and
improperly screened receptacles and docks can cause noise problems for nearby
land uses when the receptacles and packages are being loaded or unloaded.
Therefore, they should be located as far from public sidewalks as possible
and screened from view.
Sidewalks
Sufficiently Wide and Aligned for Convenience
Sidewalks, when properly
dimensioned and maintained, can provide the pedestrian with a pleasant,
safe, and convenient place to walk. Sidewalks that are too narrow are
inconvenient, especially in areas with large volumes of pedestrians, pedestrians
walking side-by-side (which requires a minimum sidewalk width of five
feet unobstructed), and people using wheelchairs. In addition, sidewalks
that must wrap around large block faces are a serious impediment to pedestrian
convenience.
Building
Oriented to the Street, Instead of Turning Its Back to It
A successful
commercial establishment is designed to provide convenience for customers
by minimizing walking distances from public sidewalks and nearby buildings.
Rear or side entrances, or entrances oriented toward a parking lot, make
travel highly inconvenient for pedestrians and transit users. Such a design
also cuts the building off from street life. In addition, a building with
its main entrance directed away from the primary sidewalk and street "turns
its back" to the public realm, reduces urban vibrancy, and is harmful
to promoting street life. When a building is located at an intersection,
the most convenient entrance is usually abutting the public sidewalks
at the corner of the intersection. Often, the most convenient sidewalk
is formally aligned diagonally and aligned straight to minimize walking
distance.
Facade
Treatment Creates Interest for Pedestrians
All
building shall be designed to provide interest for pedestrians. Long
expanses of blank walls tend to be boring and unattractive for the
pedestrian. In addition, windows attract pedestrians, which act as a
security system for the business. Buildings without such relief and interest tend to create a "massive scale",
and makes the public realm impersonal. Such an appearance is inconsistent
with the "human-scaled" and pedestrian-oriented character of the a traditional
area of a city, and inconsistent with a city intent to restore such character
to the traditional city area.
Hidden
Outdoor Mechanical Equipment
Outdoor
mechanical equipment, such as heating or AC units, when improperly located
on a site or improperly screened, can contribute to noise problems and
create visual blight.
Formal
Landscaping
In the traditional,
pedestrian-oriented areas of a city, landscaping should be used both to
soften the "hardness" of the urban area for the pedestrian, and make the
pedestrian feel more comfortable by providing cooling, reducing glare
and helping to form public spaces, "outdoor rooms," and street corridor
edges. Such formality of landscaping adds dignity to the traditional area
of a city, instead of a chaotic one, thereby inspiring a sense of civic
pride.
Properly
Scaled Lighting
Lighting can often
detract from the intimate, pleasant, romantic character a city seeks to
promote in the traditional, pedestrian-oriented areas of a city. But lighting
designed for cars tends to be not human-scaled. Lights on tall fixtures
cause light pollution by casting light into areas not needed by pedestrians.
In addition, the lights present a poor, bleached out atmosphere as the
pedestrian views an area from afar, and hides the nighttime sky completely.
A new urbanist, pedestrian-oriented street lighting design features shorter
and more numerous light fixtures and structures.
Prohibited
Auto-Oriented Uses
Certain
uses are oriented toward or designed to attract motor vehicles, and therefore
contribute to danger, visual blight, inconvenience, and lack of human
scale for pedestrians. Therefore, such uses are not compatible with the
a people-friendly downtown area.
Alleys
Alleys allow the developer
to place garages, driveways, waste receptacles, and overhead utilities
in a less conspicuous location away from the public street and therefore
less likely to detract from the pedestrian ambiance of the neighborhood.
Alleys also provide an additional location for emergency vehicles to gain
access to a building, and a relatively safe place for children to play.
Narrow,
Smaller Lots
Provides a more compact,
walkable arrangement of houses. Provides a more pleasing alignment of
houses along the streetside sidewalk, which enhances civic pride in the
neighborhood and makes the residential street seem more "cozy." Blocks
are reduced in size, which makes the neighborhood more walkable. Narrower
lots increase the frequency of front doors along the street, which greatly
enhances the vibrancy of the street. Houses appear to be associated in
a neighborly way, instead of isolated and cocooned from the neighborhood.
Smaller lots also make home ownership in such a subdivision more affordable.
In addition, the higher, yet livable, density that smaller lots provide
makes transit more viable.
Connected
Streets
Makes walking,
bicycling, and using the bus more feasible by significantly reducing trip
distances and increasing the number of safe and pleasant routes for such
travellers. Provides motorists and emergency service vehicles with more
"real time" route choices. A route that is impeded or blocked can be avoided
in favor of a clear route, which is not possible on a cul-de-sac. In combination
with the fact that connected streets distribute vehicle trips more evenly,
real time route choices on connected streets reduce congestion on collector
or arterial roads. As a result of this distribution, there is little or
no need for neighborhood-hostile collectors or arterials, which, because
of the volume and speed of vehicle trips they carry, are unpleasant for
residences to locate along.
|