|
1.
Introduction
This report outlines
the proposal by the Australian and New Zealand Governments to create a
new location called the Anzac Commemorative Site.
Because of
the growing number of overseas visitors attending the Anzac dawn service
on the 25 April each year, there is an urgent need to move the service
from the current site at the Ari Burnu War Cemetery.
The new site
will also serve the needs of visitors throughout the year by assisting
in the interpretation of the Anzac area as defined by the treaty of Lausanne
1923. This area forms part of the Battlefield Heritage Zone in the proposed
Peace Park that incorporates the whole of the Gallipoli Peninsula. The
Peace Park is currently under master planning development with the broad
principles of the Park established in a preliminary form. Briefly these
principles include:
- The concept of movement as a basis of reflection
- The balance of conservation of natural, archaeological
and battlefield areas with accessibility to the public
- Conserve, restore and rehabilitate the environmental,
cultural, historical and human assets of the park, yet allow for demarcation,
display, use and restricted development
- Monitor change in the social, cultural, economic
and physical character of the park.
The proposal seeks
to conform with these principles and in so doing form a positive contribution
to the Peace Park and provide recognition of the level of international
support for this initiative for world peace.
2.
Present Situation
Background
The
popularity of the Anzac dawn service held on the 25th April of each year
is growing, both in Australia and New Zealand and at sites throughout
the world. These services commemorate the involvement of the Allied forces,
particularly the Australians and New Zealanders, in the campaign of 1915
to overcome Turkish resistance and take control of the Dardanelles. Over
the years this growing popularity has led to a situation where the traditional
area for the service, being Ari Burnu War Cemetery, is suffering permanent
damage to the graves, plantings and the fabric of the place.
These concerns led
to a review of the situation where an opportunity was identified to provide
a more appropriate location for the dawn service. This is also pertinent
for the level of visitation on a year round basis. This level of activity
is a direct result of the significance Gallipoli has for Australia and
New Zealand in the forming of the identity of their respective nations.
Young Turkish nationals are also wishing to learn the reasons for this
growing interest shown in their country by the visitors.
The Battlefield
Heritage Zone has been recently included in the cultural tour circuit
that takes in Troy, Ephesus and Cape Helles. These tours have wide international
appeal with tourists coming from around the world notably the USA, Canada,
Great Britain, Germany and other European countries.
The following estimates
of attendees indicate this rising popularity:
| 1995 |
4,500 |
| 1996 |
5000 |
| 1997 |
6000 |
| 1998 |
7,500 |
| 1999 |
8,500 |
| 2000 |
expecting 10 - 12,000 |
There is a growing
realisation within Australia and New Zealand that our nations' interest
in Gallipoli will never wain because of its indelible link to the formation
of our national identities. A permanent site is needed to meet this growing
demand, a demand widely recognised and appreciated by Turkish authorities.
Much of the visitation
that the area is experiencing is in the nature of a pilgrimage, which
on Australia and New Zealand's behalf started immediately after World
War One. Veterans' organisations were originally responsible for commemorating
their lost comrades, but the pilgrimage to Gallipoli has grown in significance
to encompass people from all walks of life.
While the primary purpose of the visitation is to learn
of the war experience, the reality is that the theme is of universal suffering,
including the losses suffered by the Turkish military in what is referred
to by the Turkish people as the Battle of Cannakale. For Australian and
New Zealand visitors, the international dimension of this campaign and
particularly the full extent of war casualties, provides an experience
which broadens their understanding.
3. The
Site
The features of the Gallipoli Peninsula have been comprehensively
described in the documentation prepared by the Turkish authorities which
formed part of the brief for the international Gallipoli Peace Park Ideas
Competition held in 1998. Briefly, the cultural features of the Battlefield
Heritage Zone are characterised by a number of Turkish and Allied cemeteries
and monuments with road access providing the main form of connection between
these.
The cultural
features of the shoreline around the Ari Burnu and North Beach area are
the coastal road, Ari Burnu Cemetery, Canterbury Cemetery, Beach Cemetery
and the works depot of Commonwealth War Graves Commission.
4.
Physical Outline
4.i.
Climate
A combination of Mediterranean and Black Sea climates
is a feature of the area with much of the precipitation falling in winter.
The area experiences cold winters with occasional snow and hot dry summers.
Temperatures vary from below freezing with a recorded maximum of 38.7
Celsius in summer.
4.ii. Topography
The area is of a rugged character with a coastal
plain that varies from minimal to 200 metres in width. It forms the base
of the mountain range, which rises between 50 and 100 metres above the
coastal strip and features a number of distinctive ridges including the
"Sphinx", so named by the Anzac forces as having a similarity to the Sphinx
in Egypt, where their basic training was undertaken prior to the engagement
of 1915. The slopes vary from around 1 in 7 to 1 in 13 in the North Beach
area of the Coastal Plain to 1 in 1 or steeper in the ridgeline behind.
4.iii.
Soils
The soils are a coarse granular type reflecting the underlying geology
primarily of sandstone, shale and thin limestone. They are sensitive to
frequency of usage and are erodible with the vegetation cover removed.
4.iv. Drainage
Patterns
The drainage patterns are characterised by a sharply
defined fluvial pattern made distinctive as a result of the topography
described above. Areas of concentrated drainage have led to erosion and
surface runoff with the result that culverts under the road are blocked
and remedial works are required to stabilise sections of the area.
4.v. Sea
Currents
The coastal location exposes the area to the local
marine influences with erosion being experienced along parts of the coastal
edge due to winter storms. This has led to a degree of erosion of the
headlands with the result that the coastal edge of Ari Burnu Cemetery
has received substantial remedial works to counter wave action, the road
adjacent to Anzac Cove is gradually being undermined and Beach Cemetery
is to be stabilised in the near future. The area north of Ari Burnu is
more stable, but still shows evidence of wave action.
4.vi. Vegetation
The dominant vegetation is the native heath typical
of the Mediterranean Floristic Region. It forms a dense cover of up to
two metres in height to the lower slopes of the ridge and the coastal
plain. The middle and upper slopes of the ridge are characterised by soil
and rock. Where the vegetation is disturbed, the soil is subject to erosion
with remedial measures required for reinstatement.
5.
The Proposal
5.i. Background
The proposed commemorative area is located at
North Beach within the Battlefield Heritage Zone of the proposed Peace
Park. The infrastructure allowed within this zone under the proposed Peace
Park guidelines is in relation to the display and maintenance of the battlefields.
In the selection of the site, two areas were assessed. These were the
area adjacent to Ari Burnu Cemetery and a location 350 metres north, adjacent
to North Beach. The area adjacent to the Cemetery is located between the
existing road and the sea front. It forms a roughly triangular piece of
land with its focus being the northern wall of the cemetery. It has a
cross fall of approximately 1:6 with the remnants of a World War II gun
emplacement adjacent to the seashore. Part of the site forms a maintenance
access for the cemetery and turning area for tourist buses with the remainder
of the site being the native heath of the area. It has maximum capacity
(if cleared) of around 7000 people.
The North
Beach site features an even grade of around 1:12 across the coastal plain
with a short steep bank of around 3 metres in height adjacent to the water's
edge. To the west is the sea with the "Sphinx" forming the visual curtilage
to the east. The site is located between two drainage swales and covered
in a low native heath that has been trimmed for surveying purposes. The
coastal road is located through the site approximately 50 metres behind
the seashore. The site has a capacity of 15,000 people.
Of the two
sites, the North Beach site is the preferred location as it provides the
capacity for the expected numbers of people. An opportunity for the interpretation
of the 1915 campaign exists with its focus being the two main physical
entities of the area: the sea and the "Sphinx".
5.ii. The Concept
The concept
of the design is to engage and highlight an understanding and respect
for the meaning of Gallipoli and its significance to Turkey, Australia
and New Zealand and the world community. The proposed Peace Park uses
the concept of movement as a basis of reflection. This is highlighted
on the site through the sense of a journey from a distant land to the
shore of the Gallipoli Peninsula. The proposed design highlights the junction
of sea and land, focusing on the natural elements of the place.
The native
vegetation is retained, local stone is used in the built elements and
rehabilitation will occur in areas that are currently degraded around
the site.
5.iii. Design
Elements
1. A focal area
of the annual dawn service is located adjacent to the beach and highlights
the connection of the sea and land. Access towards the sea and a connecting
pathway system to Ari Burnu and the existing road is provided. This path
is a most important element of the design, since the dawn service will
conclude with visitors returning to the cemetery. The current eroded bank
to the sea will be reformed and stabilised.
2., A low wall is proposed
adjacent to the existing road that will provide a location for the facilitation
of the interpretation of the campaign. This wall will also assist in the
stabilisation of the road. The paths will assist with the movement of
the official party through the crowded site before daylight.
3. The areas of vegetation
will be rehabilitated. Native border plants will create a gathering area
for the dawn service. The area broadly describes a parabola in form and
takes as its inspiration the topography of the environs. As this area
is used intensively once a year, the native vegetation that exists will
be retained and managed so as to facilitate the use of the space. To the
outside of the parabola form, the native vegetation will be rehabilitated.
6.
Principles
The proposal follows the principles as outlined for
the Peace Park:
6.i.
Environmental
- Recognition of existing drainage patterns and
rehabilitation of existing drainage works
- Consolidation of the beachfront currently suffering erosion
- Retention and rehabilitation of native vegetation
- Use of local natural materials including stone and gravel
- Minimal visual intrusion through careful design
of elements
6.ii.
Heritage historical principle
- Sympathetic to Peace Park philosophy - Journey
- Recognition of Battlefield Heritage Zone
- Interpretation through understanding of campaign
6.iii. Cultural
principles
- Accommodation of visitation, cultural tourism,
recognition of numbers
- Provision of amenity so not to compromise the
place
- Seek to celebrate the common heritage of Australia,
New Zealand and Turkey
6.iii.
Human assets
- Provide place for pilgrimage and interpretation
for all.
7.
Conclusion
The proposed Anzac Commemorative site has been carefully
selected to provide an appropriate amenity for the ceremonial and cultural
tourism activities at Gallipoli. The site's physical character has been
carefully assessed to accommodate the proposed functions. The low scale
of the built elements, the provision of linking paths and the rehabilitation
and conservation of native vegetation is consistent with the objectives
of the proposed Peace Park.
The Australian and
New Zealand Governments sought permission of the Turkish Government to
construct this commemorative site for Anzac Day services and to inform
visitors throughout the year of the events which took place at Gallipoli.
This request was made in full recognition of Turkish sovereignty over
the area in question and with acknowledgement of the importance of the
whole Gallipoli Peninsula to the people of Turkey.
|