|
Greek
philosopher and scientist, who shares with Plato and Socrates the distinction
of being the most famous of ancient philosophers.
Aristotle was born at Stagira, in Macedonia, the son of a physician
to the royal court. At the age of 17, he went to Athens to study at
Plato's Academy. He remained there for about 20 years, as a student
and then as a teacher.
When Plato died in 347 BC, Aristotle moved to Assos, a city in Asia
Minor, where a friend of his, Hermias, was ruler. There he counseled
Hermias and married his niece and adopted daughter, Pythias. After Hermias
was captured and executed by the Persians in 345 BC, Aristotle went
to Pella, the Macedonian capital, where he became the tutor of the king's
young son Alexander, later known as Alexander the Great. In 335, when
Alexander became king, Aristotle returned to Athens and established
his own school, the Lyceum. Because much of the discussion in his school
took place while teachers and students were walking about the Lyceum
grounds, Aristotle's school came to be known as the Peripatetic ("walking"
or "strolling") school. Upon the death of Alexander in 323
BC, strong anti-Macedonian feeling developed in Athens, and Aristotle
retired to a family estate in Euboea. He died there the following year.
Works
Aristotle, like Plato, made regular use of the dialogue in his earliest
years at the Academy, but lacking Plato's imaginative gifts, he probably
never found the form congenial. Apart from a few fragments in the works
of later writers, his dialogues have been wholly lost. Aristotle also
wrote some short technical notes, such as a dictionary of philosophic
terms and a summary of the doctrines of Pythagoras. Of these, only a
few brief excerpts have survived. Still extant, however, are Aristotle's
lecture notes for carefully outlined courses treating almost every branch
of knowledge and art. The texts on which Aristotle's reputation rests
are largely based on these lecture notes, which were collected and arranged
by later editors.
Among the texts are treatises on logic, called Organon ("instrument"),
because they provide the means by which positive knowledge is to be
attained. His works on natural science include Physics, which gives
a vast amount of information on astronomy, meteorology, plants, and
animals. His writings on the nature, scope, and properties of being,
which Aristotle called First Philosophy (Prote philosophia), were given
the title Metaphysics in the first published edition of his works (60?
BC), because in that edition they followed Physics. His treatment of
the Prime Mover, or first cause, as pure intellect, perfect in unity,
immutable, and, as he said, "the thought of thought," is given
in the Metaphysics. To his son Nicomachus he dedicated his work on ethics,
called the Nicomachean Ethics. Other essential works include his Rhetoric,
his Poetics (which survives in incomplete form), and his Politics (also
incomplete).
Methods
Perhaps because of the influence of his father's medical profession,
Aristotle's philosophy laid its principal stress on biology, in contrast
to Plato's emphasis on mathematics. Aristotle regarded the world as
made up of individuals (substances) occurring in fixed natural kinds
(species). Each individual has its built-in specific pattern of development
and grows toward proper self-realization as a specimen of its type.
Growth, purpose, and direction are thus built into nature. Although
science studies general kinds, according to Aristotle, these kinds find
their existence in particular individuals. Science and philosophy must
therefore balance, not simply choose between, the claims of empiricism
(observation and sense experience) and formalism (rational deduction).
One of the most distinctive of Aristotle's philosophic contributions
was a new notion of causality. Each thing or event, he thought, has
more than one "reason" that helps to explain what, why, and
where it is. Earlier Greek thinkers had tended to assume that only one
sort of cause can be really explanatory; Aristotle proposed four. (The
word Aristotle uses, aition, "a responsible, explanatory factor"
is not synonymous with the word cause in its modern sense.)
These four causes are the material cause, the matter out of which a
thing is made; the efficient cause, the source of motion, generation,
or change; the formal cause, which is the species, kind, or type; and
the final cause, the goal, or full development, of an individual, or
the intended function of a construction or invention. Thus, a young
lion is made up of tissues and organs, its material cause; the efficient
cause is its parents, who generated it; the formal cause is its species,
lion; and its final cause is its built-in drive toward becoming a mature
specimen. In different contexts, while the causes are the same four,
they apply analogically. Thus, the material cause of a statue is the
marble from which it was carved; the efficient cause is the sculptor;
the formal cause is the shape the sculptor realized-Hermes, perhaps,
or Aphrodite; and the final cause is its function, to be a work of fine
art.
In each context, Aristotle insists that something can be better understood
when its causes can be stated in specific terms rather than in general
terms. Thus, it is more informative to know that a sculptor made the
statue than to know that an artist made it; and even more informative
to know that Polycleitus chiseled it rather than simply that a sculptor
did so.
Aristotle thought his causal pattern was the ideal key for organizing
knowledge. His lecture notes present impressive evidence of the power
of this scheme.
Doctrines
Some of the principal aspects of Aristotle's thought can be seen in
the following summary of his doctrines, or theories.
Physics,
or Natural Philosophy
In astronomy, Aristotle proposed a finite, spherical universe, with
the earth at its center. The central region is made up of four elements:
earth, air, fire, and water. In Aristotle's physics, each of these four
elements has a proper place, determined by its relative heaviness, its
"specific gravity." Each moves naturally in a straight line-earth
down, fire up-toward its proper place, where it will be at rest. Thus,
terrestrial motion is always linear and always comes to a halt. The
heavens, however, move naturally and endlessly in a complex circular
motion. The heavens, therefore, must be made of a fifth, and different
element, which he called aither. A superior element, aither is incapable
of any change other than change of place in a circular movement. Aristotle's
theory that linear motion always takes place through a resisting medium
is in fact valid for all observable terrestrial motions. He also held
that heavier bodies of a given material fall faster than lighter ones
when their shapes are the same, a mistaken view that was accepted as
fact until the Italian physicist and astronomer Galileo conducted his
experiment with weights dropped from the Leaning Tower of Pisa.
Biology
In zoology, Aristotle proposed a fixed set of natural kinds ("species"),
each reproducing true to type. An exception occurs, Aristotle thought,
when some "very low" worms and flies come from rotting fruit
or manure by "spontaneous generation." The typical life cycles
are epicycles: The same pattern repeats, but through a linear succession
of individuals. These processes are therefore intermediate between the
changeless circles of the heavens and the simple linear movements of
the terrestrial elements. The species form a scale from simple (worms
and flies at the bottom) to complex (human beings at the top), but evolution
is not possible.
Aristotelian Psychology
For Aristotle, psychology was a study of the soul. Insisting that form
(the essence, or unchanging characteristic element in an object) and
matter (the common undifferentiated substratum of things) always exist
together, Aristotle defined a soul as a "kind of functioning of
a body organized so that it can support vital functions." In considering
the soul as essentially associated with the body, he challenged the
Pythagorean doctrine that the soul is a spiritual entity imprisoned
in the body. Aristotle's doctrine is a synthesis of the earlier notion
that the soul does not exist apart from the body and of the Platonic
notion of a soul as a separate, nonphysical entity. Whether any part
of the human soul is immortal, and, if so, whether its immortality is
personal, are not entirely clear in his treatise On the Soul.
Through the functioning of the soul, the moral and intellectual aspects
of humanity are developed. Aristotle argued that human insight in its
highest form (nous poetikos, "active mind") is not reducible
to a mechanical physical process. Such insight, however, presupposes
an individual "passive mind" that does not appear to transcend
physical nature. Aristotle clearly stated the relationship between human
insight and the senses in what has become a slogan of empiricism-the
view that knowledge is grounded in sense experience. "There is
nothing in the intellect," he wrote, "that was not first in
the senses."
Ethics
It seemed to Aristotle that the individual's freedom of choice made
an absolutely accurate analysis of human affairs impossible. "Practical
science," then, such as politics or ethics, was called science
only by courtesy and analogy. The inherent limitations on practical
science are made clear in Aristotle's concepts of human nature and self-realization.
Human nature certainly involves, for everyone, a capacity for forming
habits; but the habits that a particular individual forms depend on
that individual's culture and repeated personal choices. All human beings
want "happiness," an active, engaged realization of their
innate capacities, but this goal can be achieved in a multiplicity of
ways.
Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics is an analysis of character and intelligence
as they relate to happiness. Aristotle distinguished two kinds of "virtue,"
or human excellence: moral and intellectual. Moral virtue is an expression
of character, formed by habits reflecting repeated choices. A moral
virtue is always a mean between two less desirable extremes. Courage,
for example, is a mean between cowardice and thoughtless rashness; generosity,
between extravagance and parsimony. Intellectual virtues are not subject
to this doctrine of the mean. Aristotle argued for an elitist ethics:
Full excellence can be realized only by the mature male adult of the
upper class, not by women, or children, or barbarians (non-Greeks),
or salaried "mechanics" (manual workers) for whom, indeed,
Aristotle did not want to allow voting rights.
In politics, many forms of human association can obviously be found;
which one is suitable depends on circumstances, such as the natural
resources, cultural traditions, industry, and literacy of each community.
Aristotle did not regard politics as a study of ideal states in some
abstract form, but rather as an examination of the way in which ideals,
laws, customs, and property interrelate in actual cases. He thus approved
the contemporary institution of slavery but tempered his acceptance
by insisting that masters should not abuse their authority, since the
interests of master and slave are the same. The Lyceum library contained
a collection of 158 constitutions of the Greek and other states. Aristotle
himself wrote the Constitution of Athens as part of the collection,
and after being lost, this description was rediscovered in a papyrus
copy in 1890. Historians have found the work of great value in reconstructing
many phases of the history of Athens.
Logic
In logic, Aristotle developed rules for chains of reasoning that would,
if followed, never lead from true premises to false conclusions (validity
rules). In reasoning, the basic links are syllogisms: pairs of propositions
that, taken together, give a new conclusion. For example, "All
humans are mortal" and "All Greeks are humans" yield
the valid conclusion "All Greeks are mortal." Science results
from constructing more complex systems of reasoning. In his logic, Aristotle
distinguished between dialectic and analytic. Dialectic, he held, only
tests opinions for their logical consistency; analytic works deductively
from principles resting on experience and precise observation. This
is clearly an intended break with Plato's Academy, where dialectic was
supposed to be the only proper method for science and philosophy alike.
Metaphysics
In his metaphysics, Aristotle argued for the existence of a divine being,
described as the Prime Mover, who is responsible for the unity and purposefulness
of nature. God is perfect and therefore the aspiration of all things
in the world, because all things desire to share perfection. Other movers
exist as well-the intelligent movers of the planets and stars (Aristotle
suggested that the number of these is "either 55 or 47").
The Prime Mover, or God, described by Aristotle is not very suitable
for religious purposes, as many later philosophers and theologians have
observed. Aristotle limited his "theology," however, to what
he believed science requires and can establish.
Influence
Aristotle's works were lost in the West after the decline of Rome. During
the 9th century AD, Arab scholars introduced Aristotle, in Arabic translation,
to the Islamic world. The 12th-century Spanish-Arab philosopher Averroës
is the best known of the Arabic scholars who studied and commented on
Aristotle. In the 13th century, the Latin West renewed its interest
in Aristotle's work, and Saint Thomas Aquinas found in it a philosophical
foundation for Christian thought. Church officials at first questioned
Aquinas's use of Aristotle; in the early stages of its rediscovery,
Aristotle's philosophy was regarded with some suspicion, largely because
his teachings were thought to lead to a materialistic view of the world.
Nevertheless, the work of Aquinas was accepted, and the later philosophy
of scholasticism continued the philosophical tradition based on Aquinas's
adaptation of Aristotelian thought.
The influence of Aristotle's philosophy has been pervasive; it has even
helped to shape modern language and common sense. His doctrine of the
Prime Mover as final cause played an important role in theology. Until
the 20th century, logic meant Aristotle's logic. Until the Renaissance,
and even later, astronomers and poets alike admired his concept of the
universe. Zoology rested on Aristotle's work until British scientist
Charles Darwin modified the doctrine of the changelessness of species
in the 19th century. In the 20th century a new appreciation has developed
of Aristotle's method and its relevance to education, literary criticism,
the analysis of human action, and political analysis.
Not only the discipline of zoology, but also the world of learning as
a whole, seems to amply justify Darwin's remark that the intellectual
heroes of his own time "were mere schoolboys compared to old Aristotle."
|